A proposal for North Carolina

North Carolina votes purple. Its legislature should look like it.

Our statewide races are decided by a few points, yet district lines can hand one party a lopsided share of the General Assembly. This proposal fixes that by giving each party seats in proportion to its votes.

Outline of North Carolina filled with the state flag
The problem

Close elections, lopsided legislature

< 4 pts
Margin in every NC presidential race since 2008
30 of 50
NC Senate seats held by one party after 2024 (a 3/5 supermajority)
71 of 120
NC House seats held by the same party, one seat short of a supermajority

North Carolina is about as evenly divided as a state can be, and plenty of voters split their tickets. Yet the party that draws the district maps can turn a near-tie into a near-supermajority. That isn't a knock on either party. Whoever holds the pen has the same temptation, and the result is a legislature that doesn't reflect the people who elected it.

No party should be able to draw itself a majority the voters didn't give it. A truly representative legislature represents all North Carolinians.

Source: NC State Board of Elections general-election results, 2008–2024.

Exhibit A: the 2026 election

Democrats won a landslide and still lost the Senate

In November 2026, Democrats won the statewide U.S. Senate race by nearly 20 points, and they won 57.8% of every vote cast for the NC Senate. They still came away with only 24 of 50 seats. It took a wave this size to win the House at all.

NC Senate · 50 seats, 26 for a majority

Votes
57.8%41.9%
Seats
24 (48%)26 (52%)

NC House · 120 seats, 61 for a majority

Votes
59.2%39.6%
Seats
71 (59%)48 (40%)
  • Democrats
  • Republicans
  • Other parties & unaffiliated
  • Majority line (50%)
≈58.6%
Share of the two-party vote Democrats needed for a Senate majority on these maps. They got 58.0% and fell short.
≈57.5%
Needed for a House majority: a 15-point statewide win just to reach 61 seats.
75–45
Estimated Republican edge in the House if the vote were a perfect 50–50 tie. That's a veto-proof supermajority (72+).
31–19
Estimated Republican edge in the Senate in a 50–50 tie, also a supermajority (30+).

What the 2026 votes produced

  • Senate: Democrats 24, Republicans 26
  • House: Democrats 71, Republicans 48, unaffiliated 1

Same votes, proportional seats

  • Senate: Democrats 29, Republicans 21
  • House: Democrats 71, Republicans 48, others 1

The House landed close to proportional this year only because the wave cleared the ~57.5% bar. In the Senate, it didn't. Estimate: Droop quota and largest remainder applied to statewide totals. The real proposal allocates within 5 regions, which can move a seat or two.

The point isn't which party won. The 2026 maps would hand a tie to one party as a supermajority, and they made the other party win by 15–20 points just to control one chamber. Under this proposal, seats would simply follow the votes, in a wave year or a tied one.

Show the numbers and how they were calculated
2026 NC legislative votes and seats
ChamberPartyVotesVote %Seats wonSeat %Proportional
NC SenateDemocrats2,357,47857.8%2448.0%29
NC SenateRepublicans1,708,67741.9%2652.0%21
NC SenateOther parties & unaffiliated13,7150.3%00.0%0
NC HouseDemocrats2,357,11959.2%7159.2%71
NC HouseRepublicans1,574,64939.6%4840.0%48
NC HouseOther parties & unaffiliated47,4121.2%10.8%1
  • Source: NC State Board of Elections precinct-level results for November 3, 2026 (results_pct_20261103, updated November 14, 2026). These results are unofficial until certified.
  • Uncontested seats: 25 House and 5 Senate Democrats ran unopposed, versus 4 and 1 Republicans. That inflates the Democratic share of raw legislative votes. As a cross-check, the statewide U.S. Senate race, which every voter could vote in, went 58.8% Democratic to 39.1% Republican.
  • "Needed for a majority" and "50–50 tie": these come from a uniform-swing estimate. Each district's two-party Democratic share is shifted by the same amount until the statewide average reaches the target, and then we count who would win each seat.
How gerrymandering works

Same voters, different lines, different winners

Below are 50 voters: 30 for Gold (60%) and 20 for Purple (40%). They must be split into 5 districts of 10 voters each. Nobody changes their vote. Only the lines move.

  • Gold voter
  • Purple voter
  • Thick lines = district borders

    • Even lines: Gold wins 3 districts, Purple wins 2, matching the vote.
    • Cracked: every district has 6 Gold and 4 Purple voters. Gold wins 5–0.
    • Packed: Gold voters are crammed into 2 districts, and Purple wins the other 3 narrowly. The 40% party wins the majority.
    • This proposal: one 5-seat district split by vote share. Gold 3, Purple 2, no matter where the lines go.
    The fix, in three steps

    How the proposal works

    1. Five big regions

      The state is divided into 5 regions of roughly equal population. Each region elects 10 senators and 24 House members. The legislature keeps its current size: 50 and 120.

    2. Vote for a party slate

      Parties pick a ranked list of candidates in a primary. In November you cast one vote for the slate you prefer in each chamber.

    3. Seats follow votes

      Each party wins seats in proportion to its share of the vote in your region, filled from the top of its slate. 30% of the vote gets about 30% of the seats.

    A quick example

    One region, 10 Senate seats

    Say 800,000 people vote in a region. Here's how its 10 Senate seats would be split:

    • Party A: 30.7% of votes → 3 seats
    • Party B: 23.6% of votes → 2 seats
    • Party C: 17.3% of votes → 2 seats
    • Party D: 28.3% of votes → 3 seats

    Under winner-take-all, the first-place party (Party A, with under 31%) could win every seat, and the other 69% of voters would elect no one.

    See exactly how those seats are calculated →